BLOG › Casual conversion: The pros and cons of moving a casual to permanent part-time

Casual conversion: The pros and cons of moving a casual to permanent part-time

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Insights

IN SHORT
When a long-term casual asks to go permanent, small businesses must respond in writing within 21 days on limited grounds, and getting it wrong can lead to Fair Work Commission orders and penalties.
WHAT NEXT
Checking roster records, talking with the employee, and weighing the cost of losing them helps owners make a defensible call and keep reliable staff.

If you run a café, shop or trade business, there’s a good chance some of your best workers are casuals. Hospitality and retail have the two biggest casual workforces in the country*.

Accommodation and food services

484,000

casual employees

Cafés, restaurants, pubs and hotels

Retail trade

425,200

casual employees

Shops, supermarkets and online stores

*Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics, Working arrangements, August 2025. Figures show casual employees in their main job, by industry.

So when one asks to go permanent, it’s a big decision. You want to keep them on, but set hours and paid leave can feel like more cost than it’s worth. The Fair Work Act outlines how you need to respond, which is the easy part. The harder question is whether permanent part-time suits your business.

What is a casual working arrangement?

First, it helps to be clear on what makes someone a casual. Under the Fair Work Act, a casual employee has no firm commitment to ongoing work and is paid a casual loading or casual rate. In other words, you give them shifts as work comes up, and they can accept or decline them.

A regular pattern of hours doesn’t make someone permanent on its own, but set shifts you both expect to continue might mean they no longer fit within the definition. That’s when they can ask to go permanent through the employee choice pathway.

When a casual asks to become permanent, do you have to say yes?

Not automatically, but you do have to respond to their request, and your reasons for declining are limited.

At a small business (fewer than 15 employees), a casual can give you written notice once they’ve been with you 12 months and believe they no longer meet the definition of a casual. You’ll then need to talk it through with them and respond in writing within 21 days.

You can only say no if they still meet the casual definition, you have fair and reasonable operational grounds, or saying yes would breach a recruitment process required by law. In other words, “It’ll cost me more” isn’t a valid reason.

What changes when a casual employee becomes permanent part-time?

Moving to permanent part-time changes a few things beyond just the hourly rate:

  Casual Permanent part-time
Hourly rate Base rate plus 25% loading Base rate
Hours No guarantee – roster as needed Agreed in writing; changes require their agreement
Annual leave None Four weeks a year, pro rata
Personal leave None paid 10 days a year, pro rata
Public holidays Paid only if they work Paid if it happens on a normal workday
Ending employment Stop offering shifts Requires notice

What are the pros and cons of moving a casual to permanent part-time?

For most small businesses, it’s a matter of getting more certainty on hours and shifts. Here’s what to think about:

Pros

You keep someone trained

Replacing a good worker means recruiting and training, which can be expensive and time-consuming.

You can count on the hours

A casual can turn down any shift. A part-timer has agreed to their hours in writing, which makes your roster more predictable.

Cons

Less flexibility

A part-timer's hours are agreed in writing, and changing them needs their agreement. Depending on your award, hours outside the agreed pattern might mean you have to pay overtime.

Leave is paid

Part-timers get four weeks of annual leave and 10 days of personal leave a year, pro rata.

Public holidays cost you (even when you're closed)

If there's a public holiday on a day they normally work, they're paid for it either way. Check out our Christmas trading guide for more detail.

Letting someone go gets harder

A casual who's worked regular hours with a reasonable expectation of more can already count that time towards unfair dismissal protection. And most small businesses don't have to pay redundancy under the National Employment Standards (NES), although some awards still require it.

When should you say yes to casual conversion and when can you say no?

It depends almost entirely on how steady their hours are. Let’s imagine Marty, who runs Marty’s Café. He’s a sole trader and has had written requests from two casuals who have each been with him for more than 12 months.

Scenario 1: Why Marty says yes to a casual with set shifts

Jess has worked Tuesday to Friday, 9am to 3pm, every week for over a year. Marty expects her on those days and she’s never turned down a shift. He checks the three grounds for saying no:

Ground for saying no Does it apply to Jess?
She still meets the casual definition Unlikely. Marty rosters her on the same shifts every week, expects her to work them and the work isn’t going away.
There are fair and reasonable operational grounds No. The café needs those hours covered all year.
Saying yes would breach a recruitment process required under law No. There’s no legally required recruitment process for the role.

None apply, so Marty has to say yes, which suits him. Jess is well-trained and very reliable, so replacing her would mean recruiting and training someone new.

After talking it through with her, Marty confirms in writing within 21 days that she’ll become permanent part-time, with her hours and start date. From then, she accrues paid leave, and her hours can only change by agreement.

Scenario 2: Why Marty can say no to a casual with irregular hours

Sam’s hours rise and fall with the seasons, and Sam takes shifts when they’re offered instead of working to a set roster. Marty’s roster records for the past 12 months show the following pattern:

  Average hours per week Shifts Sam declined
December to February 30 0
March to May 14 3
June to August 6 5
September to November 16 2

Sam’s pattern of work gives Marty grounds to say no, because Sam likely still meets the definition of a casual. Marty offers work as demand allows, and Sam can (and does) turn down shifts.

Marty talks it through with Sam, then responds in writing within 21 days, setting out his reasons and the records behind them. Saying no is an option, not a requirement. If Sam is someone Marty would hate to lose, he can still say yes.

What to do before you respond to a request

Pull your roster and timesheet records for the past six to 12 months before you respond. Set shifts you both expect to continue usually mean they’re no longer casual, so you’ll need to say yes. Hours that rise and fall with demand may give you grounds to say no.

Either way, the records are your evidence.

What happens if you say no to a casual’s request to go permanent?

You can, as long as you have a valid reason. Just be aware your casual might choose to leave.

Put your reasons in writing and be very specific. If the employee disagrees, they can take it to the Fair Work Commission. They also can’t ask again for six months.

Before you say no, remember that a good casual who wants certainty might find it elsewhere.

What happens if you get a casual conversion request wrong?

Missing the 21-day deadline, skipping the conversation entirely or not giving a valid reason for saying no can cause a dispute. If it isn’t rectified at work, the Fair Work Commission can order that your employee be treated as permanent.

It’s also unlawful to misrepresent permanent employment as casual. Any breaches can attract penalties.

Making the call on a conversion request

Use this checklist to work through a conversion request:

  • Confirm they’re eligible – 12 months with you at a small business, and notice in writing.
  • Talk it through with them before you decide. It’s a required step.
  • Look at their hours over the past six to 12 months. Are they steady or fluctuating?
  • Check whether any of the three grounds for saying no apply.
  • Check the part-time rate for their classification on Fair Work’s Pay Calculator.
  • Weigh up what it would cost you to lose them.
  • Respond in writing within 21 days.

If you do end up converting a casual to a permanent staff member, their leave starts accruing and their new hours and rate need setting up. Make sure that you’ve got compliant software to help set up and pay employees, no matter the arrangement.

 

About the Author

Simon Jones

Content Writer
Simon has spent more than 15 years as a journalist and content marketer, covering a broad spectrum of topics for both print and digital mastheads. He specialises in finance and technology, with a particular interest in the intersection of AI and fintech.

Simon Jones

Content Writer
Simon has spent more than 15 years as a journalist and content marketer, covering a broad spectrum of topics for both print and digital mastheads. He specialises in finance and technology, with a particular interest in the intersection of AI and fintech.

Related Articles