Sales tax system vs VAT system
The main difference between the sales tax and VAT systems is that VAT is collected at different points of the supply chain/production process, whereas sales tax is paid once and charged at the point of sale to the final consumer.
In Australia, our VAT system is called theย Goods and Services Taxย (GST), which is charged at various points in the production process. Businesses pay and collect GST throughout the supply chain, while consumers bear the cost at the final sale.
Depending on how much GST they have received or paid, businesses may be able to claim input tax credits or pay more on theirย Business Activity Statement. Ultimately, the consumer pays the tax.
VAT system in Australia
GST is one of the Federal government’s primary revenue-raising policies.
Goods and Services Tax (GST)
GST (link) in Australia is calculated at 10% of the cost of the good or service sold. To calculate the GST on an item, you multiply the value of the cost of the good or service by 1.1. Or if you are trying to figure out the amount of GST on an item, you divide the entire price (GST inclusive) by 11.
Let’s look at an example like a $100 keyboard and find both the inclusive and exclusive:
Inclusive price:
- $100 x 1.1 =
- = $110 total price
- $10 GST component
Exclusive price:
- $100 / 11 =
- = $9.09 GST component
- = 90.91 GST exclusive price
Pros and cons of consumption tax
Value-added tax as a tax system has both pros and cons in its implementation.
Pros
Having a value-added tax system in place allows for a number of benefits to a country. Federal, state, and local governments use VAT to minimise tax loopholes affecting government revenue. Here are just a few countries that use VAT:
- Australia
- Canada
- Countries part of the European union
- United Kingdom
- Russia
- China
When a transaction occurs, the government extracts value from that transaction and collects VAT based on the value of the goods and services exchanged.
By extracting value from transactions with a flat tax, the revenue gathered is then dispersed to maintain government services and fund new projects and initiatives.
Cons
The main con of the value-added tax is that the tax burden falls on consumers, not the businesses that pay it. For example, if we were to look at a business registered for GST and charging GST on their goods and services sold, the company would only withhold the tax to release once a Business Activity Statement is completed. The consumer is not reimbursed at any stage.
VAT is criticised because it affects lower-income earners more and can be considered an indirect tax levied on them.
VAT exemptions and VAT refunds
When a value-added tax system is implemented, there are usually a few exemptions. For instance, in Australia, many items areย GST-free, and if a business pays more GST than it collects, it is entitled to a GST refund, which is considered a VAT refund or VAT return.
Like in many countries that employ VAT, in Australia, there are just a few goods and services that are GST-free:
- Some healthcare services
- some educational services
- international mail
- raw materials
What VAT means for Australian businesses
Businesses need to consider VAT depending on the country in which they operate. In Australia, businesses earning $75,000 or more over 12 months in a fiscal year must register for GST. This is part of Australia’s value-added tax registration threshold.
If your business also operates in another country that employs VAT, you must look into what tax obligations are involved in your operations. For example, VAT rates differ from country to country. In Australia, GST is a flat 10%, whereas in the United Kingdom, the VAT rate is 20%
When operating your business, you must have accounting software that properly records your income to meet your tax obligations. If you are looking to expand overseas, the ATO has resources for businesses that are looking into their obligations regarding GST and international tax systems.
